I've ordered pins from the Dizpins.com sale board, and I never pay more than $2.25 per pin (including shipping) for the kid's lanyard fodder! I usually start a post there "looking for cheap traders" a month or so before a WDW trip. I could rummage around and find a specific name or two that I've dealt with successfully if anyone wants to bump up the trust factor... but I've never had a problem.
Peace & Pins,
Andrew
