I am the same way with burgers. I don't want them to be frozen patties, this is why I love the hamburger SO very much at Turf club! It tastes like it was made with the best & juiciest Angus beef. I don't mind eating a frozen 'production' burger if I choose to at a quick service place BUT I prefer a real honest to goodness yum burger at a real restaurant!
So, Beaches & Cream... I had a VERY unfortunate incident and spilled a full coke onto my hamburger then had to wait about 30 minutes for a new one.
(I can totally laugh about that incident now, it wasn't very funny at the time)
From the bites I did take pre-spill I remember it being good but nothing spectacularly juicy or thick. I do remember the buns weren't the best, but the burgers were good. The real prize at Beaches & Cream are the desserts though & being able to drink smooth Coke in a glass bottle.
(whether it lands on your plate, or not)