[Soundgod]

Spur of the moment doesn't work, that's true for most of us, including me, when having a sit down meal. There is a difference though between totally winging it and waking up and changing your day's plans. That does still require some planning and forethought.
I'm not sure what I miss from the standard dining plan more, the appetizer or the tip. As we've done the deluxe plan a couple times now, I know it would be nice to still have the tip included. Perhaps a future optional increase of $5 per person, per day to cover the tip. Then again, maybe not.