Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge - Page 2

skwak · 05-04-2006

Voted for WL but I think both are darn nice. This is a hard choice!

Mickey, at the end of all this madness will we arrive a one final overall choice? Is this set up like March Madness?

iluvwdw · 05-04-2006

The Poly, without a doubt!!!!!!!

Wing Rider · 05-04-2006

We have stayed at both the Poly and WL. DW says she really likes WL with its rustic look from out west in Yellowstone. I have to agree the atmosphere was great. What we didn’t like was catching a bus everywhere we went. The boat ride to the MK was ok, but when we think back on convenience and service, Poly has our vote. We truly enjoyed our stay at the Poly. We would have stayed there this coming June, but they were booked. Polynesian for us.
Hurry up June!!!

JEANY031 · 05-04-2006

i love the polynesian resort because i love hawaii.

PockyMuncher · 05-04-2006

i gotta admit, the Poly's rooms are pretty cheap and sort of out-dated looking, but the Wilderness Lodge is just picturesque. However i love the Polynesian for it's theme and it's restaurant "Ohana's"

Ally Smith · 05-05-2006

We stayed at the lodge on honeymoon in Feb & absolutely loved it - the ony reason to move would be for the new experience and to try the Poly on the monorail.

Cosmicwaves · 05-05-2006

WL!!!! I wanna stay there sooo bad!

DisneyHog6 · 05-06-2006

The Poly... It's on the monorail loop and it has Ohana's...

DisneyHog6 · 05-06-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by greatwhite

Can I get my ashes scattered there does anyone know?

Just have a loved one do it... I wouldn't even ask the question. What they don't know can't hurt them...

snow'sfriend · 05-07-2006

I enjoy staying at both but have to vote for the Poly.

DisneyDude85 · 05-07-2006

I love the Poly, I have always wanted to stay at the WL but Poly holds a soft spot in my heart and memories of WDW as a child. I love the Hawaiian theme and the luaus are awesome.

MouseGoddess · 05-09-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by greatwhite

Polynesian in the first round. David v Goliath doesn't come close in terms of a mismatch.

Just returned from the Poly. Everything about it makes me happy.

Can I get my ashes scattered there does anyone know?

I don't know if they allow it, but I've sworn my family to do it somehow!

**roxie** · 05-09-2006

I voted for WL because it is just so beautiful and I would love to stay there again.

We have stayed at the Poly, too and it sure has a lot of benefits! My family of 5 can stay there and it is on the monorail line are just two of these.

Tough vote.

KittieKChick · 05-09-2006

I like both of them, WL for the convenience of everything being in one building, and Poly for it being on the monorail and having Ohana. That being said, I did choose WL. It's tough though, because both are very nice, and beautiful.

skwak · 05-09-2006

Wow, I am surprised that the Poly is beating WL by this much!

View Poll Results: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge
Polynesian	58	61.70%
Wilderness Lodge	36	38.30%
Voters: 94. You may not vote on this poll

05-04-2006	#16 (permalink)
skwak Pay me in Disney Dollars! Join Date: Aug 2002 Location: New Jersey Posts: 2,492	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge Voted for WL but I think both are darn nice. This is a hard choice! Mickey, at the end of all this madness will we arrive a one final overall choice? Is this set up like March Madness? __________________ 2008 Oct. ~ SSR & 7 Days on the Disney Magic! 2008 Aug ~ Our New Vacation Home 2008 Apr. ~ Our New Vacation Home 2007 Dec. ~ Swan & VWL 2007 Aug. ~ POR & Contemporary 2006 Nov. ~ SSR, ASM and 7 Days on the Disney Magic! 2005 Oct. ~ VWL 2005 Apr. ~ BWV 2004 Oct. ~ OKW 2004 Sept. ~ SSR 2003 Oct. ~ POR & Caribbean Beach 2002 Sept. ~ POR & AKL 2001 March ~ ASSports 2000 Feb. ~ All Star Sports & Coronado Springs My Disney Countdown Counting down to: 8 Nights at Goofy's Grotto with the Entlers and Bussenos!! Gone to our Happy Place!

05-04-2006	#17 (permalink)
iluvwdw BLT for me! Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Floral Park Village (Long Island), NY Posts: 7,413	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge The Poly, without a doubt!!!!!!! __________________ Kim LIFE IS JUST BETTER WHEN YOU HAVE A DISNEY TRIP PLANNED! 1997 Double Tree ~ 1998 Vistana ~ 1999 April Vistana ~ 1999 July Vistana ~ 1999 Sept All Star Movies ~ 2000 Vistana ~ 2001 Vistana ~ 2002 Vistana ~ 2003 Aug Vistana ~ 2003 Dec All Star Sports, Polynesian & OKW ~ 2004 Feb Vistana ~ 2004 Dec Vistana ~ 2005 Vistana/All Star Music 2006 SSR and Vistana Villages ~ 2007 Sheraton Safari, Vistana, POP Century ~ 2008 Vistana Villages, Animal Kingdom Villas My Disney Countdown Counting down to: Our First Stay at BLT as DVC Members - President's Week 2010! 79 days 8 hours 28 minutes

05-04-2006	#19 (permalink)
JEANY031 Big Rescue Rangers fan Join Date: Jul 2003 Location: MIAMI,FL Posts: 1,745	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge i love the polynesian resort because i love hawaii. __________________ JEANY SANCHEZ MUSKETEER I Mickey Mouse 3 Musketeers Jeany, Ingamba, Erin! I Erin! I Ingamba I Epcot I Rescue Rangers October 2006- Pop Century March 2007- Disney's Port Orleans Resort-Riverside May 2007- Disney's Coronado Springs Resort Nov 2007- Disney's All Star Music Oct 2008- Disney's All Star Music May 2009- POP Century Nov 2009- Disney's All-Star Movies resort

05-04-2006	#20 (permalink)
PockyMuncher Mouseketeer Join Date: May 2006 Location: Massachusetts Posts: 80	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge i gotta admit, the Poly's rooms are pretty cheap and sort of out-dated looking, but the Wilderness Lodge is just picturesque. However i love the Polynesian for it's theme and it's restaurant "Ohana's" __________________ (Most recent visit to WDW) Feb. 2006 - Saratoga Springs Growing Up with WDW since 1987

		MouseBuzz.com > MouseBuzz.com > Front Page Polls
Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge

05-04-2006	#18 (permalink)
Wing Rider Senior Mouseketeer Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Louisville, Ohio Posts: 130	We have stayed at both the Poly and WL. DW says she really likes WL with its rustic look from out west in Yellowstone. I have to agree the atmosphere was great. What we didn’t like was catching a bus everywhere we went. The boat ride to the MK was ok, but when we think back on convenience and service, Poly has our vote. We truly enjoyed our stay at the Poly. We would have stayed there this coming June, but they were booked. Polynesian for us. Hurry up June!!!

05-05-2006	#21 (permalink)
Ally Smith Baby MouseBuzzer Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 1	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge We stayed at the lodge on honeymoon in Feb & absolutely loved it - the ony reason to move would be for the new experience and to try the Poly on the monorail.

05-05-2006	#22 (permalink)
Cosmicwaves Mouse Meister Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: CT Posts: 1,387	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge WL!!!! I wanna stay there sooo bad! __________________ 1985-Off site 1986-Off site 1988-DL-Off site August 1989-The Buena Vista Palace March 1997-All Star Music March 2000-All Star Movies January 2002-All Star Music October/Nov 2002-Off site January2005-Off site January2006-Off site September 2006-POR September/October 2007-Off site August 2008-DL-Off site: Alpine Inn My Disney Countdown Counting down to: Baby's Arrival! Baby is Here!

05-06-2006	#23 (permalink)
DisneyHog6 A Hog Fan's Life For Me! Join Date: Apr 2002 Location: Stationed in Dover, De, but from Arkansas-GO HOGS!!! Posts: 2,791	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge The Poly... It's on the monorail loop and it has Ohana's... __________________ Dewey-"DewMan" Proud member of U.S. Air Force. 21 Trips to WDW 85-06 1 Trip to DL Paris Jul 2005 Next trip - June 07 Got a MySpace? Visit mine... http://www.myspace.com/DewMan616 Yet ANOTHER R2G avatar creation... I'll have three Grande Locos, with Juice in a to go cup, please! WOO PIG SOOIE! Join the Redneck Revolution! I'm an alicefanMAN! If Heaven ain't a lot like Dixie, I don't wanna go...

05-07-2006	#25 (permalink)
snow'sfriend Senior Mouseketeer Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Neverland Posts: 371	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge I enjoy staying at both but have to vote for the Poly.

05-07-2006	#26 (permalink)
DisneyDude85 Senior Mouseketeer Join Date: May 2005 Location: Pawtucket, RI Posts: 146	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge I love the Poly, I have always wanted to stay at the WL but Poly holds a soft spot in my heart and memories of WDW as a child. I love the Hawaiian theme and the luaus are awesome. __________________ Disney Fan since 1985 Polyensian Resort May 1989 - May 2003 Animal Kingdom Lodge - October 2004, May 2005, October 2005, May 2006, May 2007

05-09-2006	#28 (permalink)
roxie Invisible Woman Join Date: Feb 2003 Posts: 2,549	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge I voted for WL because it is just so beautiful and I would love to stay there again. We have stayed at the Poly, too and it sure has a lot of benefits! My family of 5 can stay there and it is on the monorail line are just two of these. Tough vote.

05-09-2006	#29 (permalink)
KittieKChick Big Cheese Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: North Carolina Posts: 855	Re: Death Match: Polynesian vs. Wilderness Lodge I like both of them, WL for the convenience of everything being in one building, and Poly for it being on the monorail and having Ohana. That being said, I did choose WL. It's tough though, because both are very nice, and beautiful. __________________ Brandy - Mommy to a 'May 2007' Princess! ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Happiness is having a Disney trip planned. oh yeah, and having the family to go with you. Correction: I now know that the family is optional. Por Favor Mantengase Alejado De Las Puertas **19901997200020052006-Belated Honeymoon2009***

05-09-2006	#30 (permalink)
skwak Pay me in Disney Dollars! Join Date: Aug 2002 Location: New Jersey Posts: 2,492	Wow Wow, I am surprised that the Poly is beating WL by this much! __________________ 2008 Oct. ~ SSR & 7 Days on the Disney Magic! 2008 Aug ~ Our New Vacation Home 2008 Apr. ~ Our New Vacation Home 2007 Dec. ~ Swan & VWL 2007 Aug. ~ POR & Contemporary 2006 Nov. ~ SSR, ASM and 7 Days on the Disney Magic! 2005 Oct. ~ VWL 2005 Apr. ~ BWV 2004 Oct. ~ OKW 2004 Sept. ~ SSR 2003 Oct. ~ POR & Caribbean Beach 2002 Sept. ~ POR & AKL 2001 March ~ ASSports 2000 Feb. ~ All Star Sports & Coronado Springs My Disney Countdown Counting down to: 8 Nights at Goofy's Grotto with the Entlers and Bussenos!! Gone to our Happy Place!

User Name		Remember Me?
Password

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Death Match: Fort Wilderness vs. Pop Century	mickey	Front Page Polls	34	02-14-2008 10:08 AM
Death Match: Animal Kingdom Lodge vs. Wilderness Lodge	mickey	Front Page Polls	27	09-13-2006 07:11 AM
Death Match: Boardwalk Villas vs. Villas at Wilderness Lodge	mickey	Front Page Polls	20	02-12-2006 09:15 PM
FAQ Disney's Wilderness Lodge	DisneyTeacher	WDW Resort FAQs	0	02-17-2005 11:30 AM
Polynesian....or Wilderness Lodge?	SilentRascal	WDW Resorts	28	03-04-2003 10:39 AM