Free dining better than new discount packages??

SnazzyCMB · 08-19-2006

Ok, so we have our package booked for 8 nights at the beach club with free dining/park hopper/water park and more for 9/29-10/7. Now, a few discounts have come out on packages, and I'm just wondering if I should rebook without free dining?? I mean, it is 2 adults, so we are saving about 76/night with free dining. Does anyone know if the package discounts are better than that?? So confused, what do I do?? help please!

bethishooked · 08-19-2006

I would stick with keeping the free dining. Even if the discount saves a few bucks more, you probably will get much more with the free dining. What I mean is we just used our free dining package. On previous trips, we watched what we spent, only going to one table service to keep funds in check, and ordering affordable meals at the counter service. With the free dining, I ordered what I actually wanted, at a much more expensive restaurant than I would ever go to. It was a great experience.

SnazzyCMB · 08-19-2006

See, my dilemma isn't really about the dining plan. I've used the dining plan last year (it was free then too

). I would definitely use it, even if we had to pay for it. If we paid for it, it would cost around 76/night. If the discount could save us more than that, it would make more sense though, right? Or am I just being crazy and overthinking everything??

E&B's Mom · 08-19-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by SnazzyCMB

See, my dilemma isn't really about the dining plan. I've used the dining plan last year (it was free then too

). I would definitely use it, even if we had to pay for it. If we paid for it, it would cost around 76/night. If the discount could save us more than that, it would make more sense though, right? Or am I just being crazy and overthinking everything??

Sounds logical to me. As long as you would save more than $76 per night and you can add the dinning plan onto it, why not?

**Dana** · 08-19-2006

I honestly would keep it as is. I think that having the dining plan will give you the freedom to choose restaurants you may not normally choose. you can also order things and not worry about spending the money on something you may or may not like. Sometimes a clear head is better than saving a few bucks. I know that I hesitate in spending to much money on things if I am unsure if I will like them. If the meal is free, I would be a bit more spontaneous with my choices. That's just me of course. If you can save more than $76 a night with the new package, then go for it. I am not sure if you are allowed to combine different specials, so I have no clue if you would be able to add free dining to another special.

SnazzyCMB · 08-19-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dana

If you can save more than $76 a night with the new package, then go for it. I am not sure if you are allowed to combine different specials, so I have no clue if you would be able to add free dining to another special.

The 76 is the amount I would have to spend to add the dining plan and pay for it. I'm trying to determine if it's better to pay for the dining plan, but get a better discount on the package/room rate with the new deals. Because basically, with free dining, I'm paying rack rate and saving 76/night because dining is free. It's confusing, I know...I just don't know what the discount on the beach club would be during those dates. If it's less than 76/night, and we'd have to pay that much for the dining plan, it's not worth it...make sense?? My brain is starting to hurt thinking about it all!

**mickey** · 08-19-2006

The discounts would be about $70 per night at the Beach Club for your stay, around $77 with tax. It is pretty much a wash for you. I personally don't think it is worth the hassle to make the change. I would just plan your dining and get ready for your trip.

**Dana** · 08-19-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by SnazzyCMB

The 76 is the amount I would have to spend to add the dining plan and pay for it. I'm trying to determine if it's better to pay for the dining plan, but get a better discount on the package/room rate with the new deals. Because basically, with free dining, I'm paying rack rate and saving 76/night because dining is free. It's confusing, I know...I just don't know what the discount on the beach club would be during those dates. If it's less than 76/night, and we'd have to pay that much for the dining plan, it's not worth it...make sense?? My brain is starting to hurt thinking about it all!

That is to confusing to me...lol I would keep it as is...lolol I wouldn't want the hassle on changing anything unless it saved me big time.

SnazzyCMB · 08-19-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by mickey

The discounts would be about $70 per night at the Beach Club for your stay, around $77 with tax. It is pretty much a wash for you. I personally don't think it is worth the hassle to make the change. I would just plan your dining and get ready for your trip.

Thanks for the info! The concensus seems to be to stick with what we have. I guess we will...it's just the overplanner in me gets anxiety when a discount comes out, wondering if it can be applied. Thanks for everyone's advice!

iluvwdw · 08-19-2006

Stick with what you got!

DisneyBride94 · 08-20-2006

I'm sticking with what you've got. :) Hey... we will be at BCR your exact same dates!!!!!!!!

DisneyBride94 · 08-20-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by SnazzyCMB

The 76 is the amount I would have to spend to add the dining plan and pay for it. I'm trying to determine if it's better to pay for the dining plan, but get a better discount on the package/room rate with the new deals. Because basically, with free dining, I'm paying rack rate and saving 76/night because dining is free. It's confusing, I know...I just don't know what the discount on the beach club would be during those dates. If it's less than 76/night, and we'd have to pay that much for the dining plan, it's not worth it...make sense?? My brain is starting to hurt thinking about it all!

I think the nightly savings for the new codes is like $75 a night at the BCR...so you come out about $1 ahead in the COST to you... so as you said, you could book the free dining and pay for it...to get the discount...but it seems $7 better to keep it as is... So the dining plan, either way, is better...but the skin of your teeth...

With 2 more kids (one of our three is under 3) on the free dining... we come out even further ahead keeping the dining plan...

DOes that help?

SnazzyCMB · 08-20-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by DisneyBride94

DOes that help?

Yes! Thanks very much. It does make sense to just keep what we have-as everyone has said. I just like to see the actual numbers-again, it's the overplanner in me.
Your family is going to love the beach club-it's our favorite! Have a great trip!

08-19-2006	#1 (permalink)
SnazzyCMB Big Cheese Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Manchester, CT Posts: 617	Free dining better than new discount packages?? Ok, so we have our package booked for 8 nights at the beach club with free dining/park hopper/water park and more for 9/29-10/7. Now, a few discounts have come out on packages, and I'm just wondering if I should rebook without free dining?? I mean, it is 2 adults, so we are saving about 76/night with free dining. Does anyone know if the package discounts are better than that?? So confused, what do I do?? help please! __________________ WooHoo! I am a DVC member and proud of it My Disney Countdown Counting down to: Could it be? Xmas trip to BLT? 380 days 8 hours 8 minutes

08-19-2006	#2 (permalink)
bethishooked Big Cheese Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Illinois Posts: 914	Re: Free dining better than new discount packages?? I would stick with keeping the free dining. Even if the discount saves a few bucks more, you probably will get much more with the free dining. What I mean is we just used our free dining package. On previous trips, we watched what we spent, only going to one table service to keep funds in check, and ordering affordable meals at the counter service. With the free dining, I ordered what I actually wanted, at a much more expensive restaurant than I would ever go to. It was a great experience. __________________ Sept, 2002 Animal Kingdom Lodge Sept, 2003 Caribean Beach Resort Jan, 2005 Animal Kingdom Lodge Aug, 2006 Animal Kingdom Lodge (1 Night PopCentury) June, 2007 Port Orleans French Quarter August, 2008 Animal Kingdom Lodge (1 Night Sports) April, 2009 POFQ - Beth & Mom Trip! My Disney Countdown Counting down to: BLT - MK View!!! 126 days 3 hours 38 minutes

08-19-2006	#3 (permalink)
SnazzyCMB Big Cheese Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Manchester, CT Posts: 617	Re: Free dining better than new discount packages?? See, my dilemma isn't really about the dining plan. I've used the dining plan last year (it was free then too ). I would definitely use it, even if we had to pay for it. If we paid for it, it would cost around 76/night. If the discount could save us more than that, it would make more sense though, right? Or am I just being crazy and overthinking everything?? __________________ WooHoo! I am a DVC member and proud of it My Disney Countdown Counting down to: Could it be? Xmas trip to BLT? 380 days 8 hours 8 minutes

08-19-2006	#5 (permalink)
Dana Super Mod/Packen' Kracken Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: Joisey Posts: 23,782	Re: Free dining better than new discount packages?? I honestly would keep it as is. I think that having the dining plan will give you the freedom to choose restaurants you may not normally choose. you can also order things and not worry about spending the money on something you may or may not like. Sometimes a clear head is better than saving a few bucks. I know that I hesitate in spending to much money on things if I am unsure if I will like them. If the meal is free, I would be a bit more spontaneous with my choices. That's just me of course. If you can save more than $76 a night with the new package, then go for it. I am not sure if you are allowed to combine different specials, so I have no clue if you would be able to add free dining to another special. __________________ ~82 off-site~91 off-site~97 ASMusic~ ~00 ASMovies~02 Wilderness Lodge~04 Animal Kingdom Lodge~ ~05 Animal Kingdom Lodge & Polynesian~ ~05 Port Orleans French Quarter~06 Old Key West~ ~07 Port Orleans French Quarter~08 Old Key West~ ~09 Saratoga Springs~10 Port Orleans Fench Quarter~ My Disney Countdown Counting down to: 10 day do all or die trying trip. 273 days 19 hours 38 minutes

08-19-2006	#7 (permalink)
mickey Administrator Join Date: Sep 2001 Posts: 6,232	Re: Free dining better than new discount packages?? The discounts would be about $70 per night at the Beach Club for your stay, around $77 with tax. It is pretty much a wash for you. I personally don't think it is worth the hassle to make the change. I would just plan your dining and get ready for your trip. __________________ Frank Costanza: You can drop a grand in Disney World, like that.

		MouseBuzz.com > Walt Disney World > WDW Budget Tips
Free dining better than new discount packages??

08-19-2006	#10 (permalink)
iluvwdw BLT for me! Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Floral Park Village (Long Island), NY Posts: 7,412	Re: Free dining better than new discount packages?? Stick with what you got! __________________ Kim LIFE IS JUST BETTER WHEN YOU HAVE A DISNEY TRIP PLANNED! 1997 Double Tree ~ 1998 Vistana ~ 1999 April Vistana ~ 1999 July Vistana ~ 1999 Sept All Star Movies ~ 2000 Vistana ~ 2001 Vistana ~ 2002 Vistana ~ 2003 Aug Vistana ~ 2003 Dec All Star Sports, Polynesian & OKW ~ 2004 Feb Vistana ~ 2004 Dec Vistana ~ 2005 Vistana/All Star Music 2006 SSR and Vistana Villages ~ 2007 Sheraton Safari, Vistana, POP Century ~ 2008 Vistana Villages, Animal Kingdom Villas My Disney Countdown Counting down to: Our First Stay at BLT as DVC Members - President's Week 2010! 83 days 19 hours 8 minutes

08-20-2006	#11 (permalink)
DisneyBride94 Senior Mouseketeer Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Red Sox Nation Posts: 230	Re: Free dining better than new discount packages?? I'm sticking with what you've got. :) Hey... we will be at BCR your exact same dates!!!!!!!! __________________ AP Holder Polynesion '76 Off site '78, '80, '85, '90 Port Orleans '94 (Honeymoon) Port Orleans '96 (2nd anniv.) Dixie Landings '96 Offsite '98, '98 (work & more work) Boardwalk '99 Coranado Springs '01 (Hunter's 1st trip) Old Key West '02 (Summer's 1st trip) Star Island Resort Villa, Kissemee, '03 Coronado Springs '04 (Parker's 1st trip, 10th anniv.) Coronado Springs '05 (11th anniv.) Beach Club Resort '06 (12th anniv.) Coronado Springs Sept 7-16 '07 MNSSHP 9-14

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Free Dining Plan - offered when?	hrbib21	WDW Restaurants	26	08-29-2006 12:15 AM
Free dining plan was not the same as one we paid for!	kizzmitt	WDW Restaurants	19	10-18-2005 03:51 PM
Free Dining with 3 night stay at WDW, 8/21 - 10/4, 2005	mickey	Front Page News	38	08-03-2005 10:43 PM
The Return of Free Dining!	mickeysaver	WDW Restaurants	5	07-20-2005 11:21 PM
Free Dining plan	kizzmitt	WDW Restaurants	12	06-05-2005 08:19 AM

User Name		Remember Me?
Password