Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose

mickeymotto · 08-15-2006

We just can't decide between the two. Help me decide on where to eat while at MGM on our next trip! Tell me why and suggestions on what to get there! Whats your favorite appetizer/entree/dessert.

**Dana** · 08-15-2006

Love mommas! It's my favorite MGM place to eat!

mickeymotto · 08-16-2006

I guess these aren't too popular since I only have 3 votes! Or maybe everyones

Come on...help me decide!

mickeymotto · 08-16-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dana

Love mommas! It's my favorite MGM place to eat!

Dana whats your favorites at Mamas? If we choose to go there, I would love some suggestions!

royorb1 · 08-16-2006

We tryed the Prime Time on our last trip and it was OK. Mama's has great food. We will try the Sci-Fi Diner for a Disney experience next time.

DisneyBride94 · 08-16-2006

I'm not a fan of either restaurant, but I preferred Prime Time to Mama Melroses.... Nothing special about Mama's... if you've ever been to a real Italian restaurant (which we have in spades in Massachusetts) you'll find that the Disney version pales in comparison... It's theming is nothing more than what you find in an authentic Italian restaurant... just kind of boring...

pirateprincess · 08-16-2006

We have made plans for Mama Melrose because I didn't know how keen I would be part of the entertainment with the waiter/waitress. If I could just go and eat, I would have chosen 50's Prime Time because the food sounds yummy.

PhilliesFan · 08-16-2006

We went to Mama's in July and we were presently surprised. We were there years ago and the food was soso then, but this time it was definitely far better than before. My sister ordered the Tender Steak and it was excellent, as was the Sangria! I would definitely go back.

gingita · 08-16-2006

I love the Prime Time Cafe, so I voted for that. I like comfort food on vacation, and the roast there was excellent. And it's best to go with a bigger group because it's much more entertaining that way. Especially if you play along. It makes for a fun experience.

KerryD · 08-16-2006

i love the Prime Tim Cafe at MGM have great food there

mickeymotto · 08-16-2006

Thanks for all your comments...we still haven't decided yet. Looks like Mama's is ahead of Prime Time so far...

lovemysons · 08-17-2006

We were also pleasantly surprised at Mama's. The service was outstanding , and we all enjoyed the meal, and the appetizer we had was fabulous, a bruschetta, if I remember correctly. I've never been to Prime Time, so I can't comment on that.

MerlinMatt · 08-17-2006

I voted for Mama Melrose because I tend to focus on food quality, rather than experience. I think the food is just better at Mama's.

Prime Time Cafe can be a lot of fun. If you don't have dinner there, try lunch, just to see how much fun it can be.

View Poll Results: Where should we eat?
Prime Tine Cafe	5	29.41%
Mama Melrose	12	70.59%
Voters: 17. You may not vote on this poll

08-15-2006	#1 (permalink)
mickeymotto aka CliffhangerMotto Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Not close enough to WDW! Posts: 2,726	Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose We just can't decide between the two. Help me decide on where to eat while at MGM on our next trip! Tell me why and suggestions on what to get there! Whats your favorite appetizer/entree/dessert. __________________ MickeyMotto **~~Magical Memories~~ June 1976~Offsite January 1978~Disneyland March 1995~Offsite November 2004~Universal-Royal Pacific December 2005~AKL/Disney Wonder September 2006~Wilderness Lodge February 2007~Animal Kingdom August 2007~Poly February 2009~Wilderness June 2009~Animal Kingdom Lodge http://www.mickeypath.com/id/1233809966.png My Disney Countdown Counting down to:** Well deserved, after the holidays, Adult Only Trip!! 56 days 21 hours 14 minutes

08-15-2006	#2 (permalink)
Dana Super Mod/Packen' Kracken Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: Joisey Posts: 23,782	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose Love mommas! It's my favorite MGM place to eat! __________________ ~82 off-site~91 off-site~97 ASMusic~ ~00 ASMovies~02 Wilderness Lodge~04 Animal Kingdom Lodge~ ~05 Animal Kingdom Lodge & Polynesian~ ~05 Port Orleans French Quarter~06 Old Key West~ ~07 Port Orleans French Quarter~08 Old Key West~ ~09 Saratoga Springs~10 Port Orleans Fench Quarter~ My Disney Countdown Counting down to: 10 day do all or die trying trip. 269 days 4 hours 14 minutes

08-16-2006	#3 (permalink)
mickeymotto aka CliffhangerMotto Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Not close enough to WDW! Posts: 2,726	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose I guess these aren't too popular since I only have 3 votes! Or maybe everyones Come on...help me decide! __________________ MickeyMotto **~~Magical Memories~~ June 1976~Offsite January 1978~Disneyland March 1995~Offsite November 2004~Universal-Royal Pacific December 2005~AKL/Disney Wonder September 2006~Wilderness Lodge February 2007~Animal Kingdom August 2007~Poly February 2009~Wilderness June 2009~Animal Kingdom Lodge http://www.mickeypath.com/id/1233809966.png My Disney Countdown Counting down to:** Well deserved, after the holidays, Adult Only Trip!! 56 days 21 hours 14 minutes

08-16-2006	#5 (permalink)
royorb1 Big Cheese Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Chicagoland Posts: 909	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose We tryed the Prime Time on our last trip and it was OK. Mama's has great food. We will try the Sci-Fi Diner for a Disney experience next time. __________________ Dec 1975 Feb. 2003 Caribbean Beach Feb. 2004 Contemporary Feb. 2005 PC Dec. 2005 PC Oct. 2007 Polynesian Dec. 2009 Caribbean Beach My Disney Countdown Counting down to: Pre XMas Fun! 9 days 8 hours 14 minutes

		MouseBuzz.com > Walt Disney World > WDW Restaurants
Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose

08-16-2006	#6 (permalink)
DisneyBride94 Senior Mouseketeer Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Red Sox Nation Posts: 230	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose I'm not a fan of either restaurant, but I preferred Prime Time to Mama Melroses.... Nothing special about Mama's... if you've ever been to a real Italian restaurant (which we have in spades in Massachusetts) you'll find that the Disney version pales in comparison... It's theming is nothing more than what you find in an authentic Italian restaurant... just kind of boring... __________________ AP Holder Polynesion '76 Off site '78, '80, '85, '90 Port Orleans '94 (Honeymoon) Port Orleans '96 (2nd anniv.) Dixie Landings '96 Offsite '98, '98 (work & more work) Boardwalk '99 Coranado Springs '01 (Hunter's 1st trip) Old Key West '02 (Summer's 1st trip) Star Island Resort Villa, Kissemee, '03 Coronado Springs '04 (Parker's 1st trip, 10th anniv.) Coronado Springs '05 (11th anniv.) Beach Club Resort '06 (12th anniv.) Coronado Springs Sept 7-16 '07 MNSSHP 9-14

08-16-2006	#7 (permalink)
pirateprincess Senior Mouseketeer Join Date: Jul 2006 Posts: 110	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose We have made plans for Mama Melrose because I didn't know how keen I would be part of the entertainment with the waiter/waitress. If I could just go and eat, I would have chosen 50's Prime Time because the food sounds yummy.

08-16-2006	#8 (permalink)
PhilliesFan Mouse Meister Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: South Jersey Posts: 1,356	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose We went to Mama's in July and we were presently surprised. We were there years ago and the food was soso then, but this time it was definitely far better than before. My sister ordered the Tender Steak and it was excellent, as was the Sangria! I would definitely go back. __________________ Polynesian - July 2006, Hard Rock - November 2004, Polynesian - June 2002, Off Site - April 1997, Caribbean Beach - May 1992, Polynesian - October 1988, Polynesian - June 1987 Honeymoon, Off Site - May 1981 Senior Class Trip Life Is Good! Hello, my name is Lisa My Disney Countdown Counting down to: Wedding in beautiful Destin Florida Time to plan something...

08-16-2006	#9 (permalink)
gingita MB Mommy Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Lake Buena Vista Posts: 1,516	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose I love the Prime Time Cafe, so I voted for that. I like comfort food on vacation, and the roast there was excellent. And it's best to go with a bigger group because it's much more entertaining that way. Especially if you play along. It makes for a fun experience. __________________ Ginger The List: MissyH-ddoll-MommytoMJM-Cincy-Mrspooky-Ingamba-Bali-Doughnut-HoneyBear-Erin-Cavey-Lil-Tigger-EmpressJenny-Palmickey-Disneyguru-Mickaholic4077-Janice419-Bama Rama-MissDisney-PrincessJill-Baloo85-BDavis-Princess Tessa-Daydreamer-WishUponAStar-Queensmama-Maria-Bumble-Kizzmitt-Soundgod-Catfish1999-Slartybartfest-Cousin Mike-Jen-Jenbarnwell-Ready2Go-rlander-Daisee-Lovemysons-Chastmastr-Quakercub-Val32-PrincessAlyssa-Iluvwdw-Dana-Ilama-Bosoxx65-Lurk...to be continued

08-16-2006	#10 (permalink)
KerryD Senior Mouseketeer Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 105	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose i love the Prime Tim Cafe at MGM have great food there __________________ ~Kerry~ DVC MEMBER SINCE 2005 78~Offsite 89~Offsite 92~Offsite 95~Offsite 97~Offsite 98~All Star Music 99~Offsite 01~Offsite 03~Carribean Beach 04~Coranado Springs 05~Port Orleans French Quarter 05~Port Orleans Riverside 06~Saratoga Springs 06~Old Key West 06~Saratoga Springs/Christmas in WDW

08-16-2006	#11 (permalink)
mickeymotto aka CliffhangerMotto Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Not close enough to WDW! Posts: 2,726	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose Thanks for all your comments...we still haven't decided yet. Looks like Mama's is ahead of Prime Time so far... __________________ MickeyMotto **~~Magical Memories~~ June 1976~Offsite January 1978~Disneyland March 1995~Offsite November 2004~Universal-Royal Pacific December 2005~AKL/Disney Wonder September 2006~Wilderness Lodge February 2007~Animal Kingdom August 2007~Poly February 2009~Wilderness June 2009~Animal Kingdom Lodge http://www.mickeypath.com/id/1233809966.png My Disney Countdown Counting down to:** Well deserved, after the holidays, Adult Only Trip!! 56 days 21 hours 14 minutes

08-17-2006	#12 (permalink)
lovemysons Single digits!! Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: In my house Posts: 7,716	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose We were also pleasantly surprised at Mama's. The service was outstanding , and we all enjoyed the meal, and the appetizer we had was fabulous, a bruschetta, if I remember correctly. I've never been to Prime Time, so I can't comment on that. __________________ Dopey is the boss of us. Missing the madness. Peppy is still my partner in crime. Is that you, Pu? Fabulous avatar, courtesy of the fabulous Mr. R2Go! ´¨) x¸.•´ ¸.•´¨)xxxx¸.•¨) (¸.•´xxxxxx(¸.•`xxx´¨)Make just one person happy. ´¨) My Disney Countdown Counting down to: Holidays full of magic 6 days 15 hours 44 minutes

08-17-2006	#13 (permalink)
MerlinMatt DC Grand Poohbah Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Boston Posts: 3,500	Re: Prime Time vs. Mama Melrose I voted for Mama Melrose because I tend to focus on food quality, rather than experience. I think the food is just better at Mama's. Prime Time Cafe can be a lot of fun. If you don't have dinner there, try lunch, just to see how much fun it can be. __________________ Erin's still my favorite.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

User Name		Remember Me?
Password

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Nicatene's TR... Nov.28th - Dec. 3 The rest of it!	nicatene1	Trip Reports	6	12-15-2004 02:03 PM
Trip Report-First Time at WDW	CiliaWilia	WDW Theme Parks	13	11-20-2004 05:49 PM
Dana & Sara's Jan 04 trip	Dana	Trip Reports	65	08-02-2004 08:26 AM
Which To Choose? Sci-Fi or 50's Prime Time	mamakay	WDW Restaurants	14	08-08-2002 03:04 PM
Arrival time and Check-In time	acidreignn	WDW Resorts	8	06-12-2002 12:38 AM